PagentRequest a testRequest

AI assistant that handles email and remembers context

Which AI assistants reply to email well and also remember what you told them?

27 assistants ranked

Twenty-seven assistants in our catalog took both the Email replies and the Memory tests. Instinct ranks first at 10.0, then Hark at 9.5 and Dots at 9.0. Poke and Waldo follow at 8.5, and Town at 8.0.

Top picks

  1. 1
    InstinctTop pick

    Email 10Memory 10

    Price not stated · App · 66% positive in 137 public quotes

    10.0
  2. 2
    HarkBest free option

    Email 9Memory 10

    Free tier · App

    9.5
  3. 3

    Email 10Memory 8

    Paid · App

    9.0
  4. 4

    Email 9Memory 8

    Free tier · SMS, App · 45% positive in 114 public quotes

    8.5
  5. 5

    Email 9Memory 8

    Waitlist · iMessage

    8.5
  6. 6
    TownFastest that's still good

    Email 9Memory 7Time to finish 6m 30s

    Free tier · WhatsApp, Telegram, App · 83% positive in 177 public quotes

    8.0

Top pick: highest average here. Best free option: highest among assistants you can use for free. Fastest that's still good: quickest median time to finish among those averaging 7 or more.

Full ranking

#AssistantEmailMemoryAverage
1Instinct101010.0
2Hark9109.5
3Dots1089.0
4Poke988.5
5Waldo988.5
6Town978.0
7szn798.0
8Tomo877.5
9Norton Family Assistant877.5
10Neo687.0
11Wajo / Fo777.0
12Familiar867.0
13Caddy766.5
14Luke766.5
15Gemini Spark846.0
16Nessi745.5
17Tressa555.0
18Ask Ranger465.0
19Today454.5
20OpenClaw454.5
21The Shadow444.0
22Manus444.0
23tinyNature534.0
24Joshu534.0
25Lucas354.0
26OpenInstinct343.5
27AVA343.5

How this report works

Included are assistants that took both Email replies and Memory, ranked by the average of the two. Email replies checks a reply on the original thread with times that are really free, written the way you write. Memory checks that it keeps your preferences, uses a change you make and lets you see and delete what it keeps 8 days later. This differs from the email replies report: it adds Memory and covers every assistant that took both.

How to choose

  • Check the price. Hark lists $20 a month, Poke $19 and Town $15, each with a free tier; Dots lists $100 a month; Instinct lists no price.
  • Read the permissions score before you connect an inbox. A high Memory score does not say how an assistant uses your mail.
  • Check that you can sign up. Waldo is on a waitlist.

Which AI assistant handles email and remembers me?

Instinct ranks first at 10.0 over the two tests, then Hark at 9.5 and Dots at 9.0.

What does the Memory test cover?

Whether it keeps your preferences, uses an update after you change one, and lets you see and delete what it keeps.

Does it learn my writing style?

The Email replies test checks that a reply sounds like you. It does not tell you how an assistant learns it.

Where is the email-only report?

See our report on the AI assistant that writes email replies.

What users say

Instinct · Zoë Schiffer ·

Last week it told me 'NOT TO OPEN' an email from a friend inviting me to a backyard BBQ—it turned out to be a phishing scam.

Open source
Instinct · Rex Lowther ·

Supposed to ping me when an email comes in and it doesn't for awhile.

Open source
Poke · @zsalem2675 ·

Every five is just not good enough when other services like @interaction send me alerts nearly instantly.

Open source
Poke · @sdrth ·

Tried Instinct as much I could, Poke still wins for me @interaction

Open source

Frequently asked questions

Which assistant is best for this?

Instinct leads with an average of 10.0, ahead of Hark and Dots.

Is there a good free option?

Hark is the highest-ranked assistant with a free plan, averaging 9.5.

How did you test these assistants?

Every assistant got the same published tests, word for word, scored from three checkpoints and the number of corrections it needed. Each test is on the Dimensions page.

Related reports