PagentRequest a testRequest
Assistants›OpenClaw
Overall5.1Raw average 5.1
Rank#33
Tested10 / 10Last tested
Reply time38s

Scores by dimension

Getting things done

Online taskPass
7
Travel bookingFail
3
PurchasingPartial
6
Phone callsFail
3

Communication

Email repliesFail
4

Judgment

Proactive helpPartial
5
RoutinesPass
7

Trust

Connected appsPass
7
Permissions & privacyFail
4
MemoryPartial
5

What people say 17 quotes, linked to source

u/Adorable-Rutabaga-77
· Reddit

the memory just… drifts. Had it handling a simple multi-step task and it straight-up forgot a key detail from the same conversation 20 minutes earlier.

u/NakedChapter
· Reddit

Bottom line: Hermes won. It offers a better experience because it has strong community support.

u/Signal-Inevitable-46
· Reddit

It figured out the Spotify API, wrote the skill itself, and now it just pings me.

u/Signal-Inevitable-46
· Reddit

On day 2 it tried to send an email on my behalf that I hadn't approved.

Marcus Li
· rerealize.com

Report #144788 is a critical regression naming 9.4 directly: post-agent-end memory generation fails for affected plugin setups that worked on 9.1 through 9.3.

Marcus Li
· rerealize.com

The old runtime then fails Doctor because it expects workspace_dir while the database now has owner_agent_id. You end up on 9.2 with 9.3-shaped data, which is the worst of both worlds.

Ivy
· saner.ai

setting it up via the terminal without a traditional graphical user interface can make you want to throw your router out the window.

Neeraj Nathany
· faraday.email

Best if you want control and will own the setup. Not a consumer app.

Luca Rossi
· refactoring.fm

For me, this migration had already started slowly, with experiments here and there, but got a decisive acceleration when I tried Grok Bot this month.

Bhavyadeep
· emergent.sh

my first live memory task returned an authentication error after about 25 seconds.

Daniel Brooks
· airmore.ai

It is less suitable for people who simply want a polished one-click chatbot.

Peter Yang
· creatoreconomy.so

Hermes is the agent I switched to after I found OpenClaw too unreliable.

TheModernBlog Team
· themodernblog.com

OpenClaw is a legitimately capable open-source autonomous agent framework with real coding strengths, an impressive community ecosystem, and some security considerations that developers absolutely need to understand before running it anywhere that matters.

TheModernBlog Team
· themodernblog.com

In January 2026, security researchers disclosed CVE-2026-25253, a cross-site WebSocket hijacking vulnerability rated CVSS 8.8. The vulnerability meant that any website could steal an auth token and achieve remote code execution on the host machine through a single malicious link.

TheModernBlog Team
· themodernblog.com

In February 2026, the ClawHavoc supply chain attack resulted in 341 malicious skills being uploaded to ClawHub, compromising over 9,000 installations with credential-stealing malware.

u/LobsterWeary2675
· Reddit

The short version: OpenClaw is powerful enough that I now treat it as infrastructure. It is also still rough enough that you need patience, logs, backups and a willingness to debug weird edge cases.

u/LobsterWeary2675
· Reddit

After roughly 3 month, I would not remove OpenClaw from my setup. It has crossed the line from experiment to daily infrastructure.

Quotes are short excerpts, linked to where they were posted. Posts from the company itself are labelled and left out of the positive share.