PagentRequest a testRequest

Dots alternatives: proactive AI assistants that list a free plan or a price under $100 a month

What can I use instead of Dots if I want an assistant that speaks up on its own, runs routines and follows my access rules, for under $100 a month?

12 assistants ranked

Twelve other assistants in our catalog list a free plan, a free tier or a monthly price under $100, and took at least three of the four tests for proactive help, routines, permissions and connected apps. Muse leads at 9.3 over three tests, then Pally at 8.8 over four, Town at 8.7 over three and Neo at 8.5 over four; Ollie and Poke follow at 8.0. Dots is left out of the ranking.

Top picks

  1. 1
    MuseTop pick

    Tested on 3 of 4Best: Routines10, Permissions9

    Free tier · App, WhatsApp · 47% positive in 123 public quotes

    9.3
  2. 2
    PallyBest free option

    Tested on 4 of 4Best: Routines10, Proactive9

    Free · iMessage, SMS, WhatsApp, Telegram · 86% positive in 38 public quotes

    8.8
  3. 3
    TownFastest that's still good

    Tested on 3 of 4Best: Connected apps10, Routines8Time to finish 6m 30s

    Free tier · WhatsApp, Telegram, App · 83% positive in 177 public quotes

    8.7
  4. 4

    Tested on 4 of 4Best: Proactive9, Connected apps9

    Free tier · Telegram, iMessage

    8.5
  5. 5

    Tested on 4 of 4Best: Routines9, Proactive8

    Free tier · iMessage, SMS · 76% positive in 44 public quotes

    8.0

Top pick: highest average here. Best free option: highest among assistants you can use for free. Fastest that's still good: quickest median time to finish among those averaging 7 or more.

Full ranking

#AssistantProactiveRoutinesPermissionsConnected appsAverage
1Muse—10999.3
2Pally910978.8
3Town—88108.7
4Neo98898.5
5Ollie89878.0
6Poke88—88.0
7szn7—687.0
8Vellum687—7.0
9Ask Ranger76746.0
10OpenClaw57475.8
11Nessi5—655.3
12Gemini Spark44454.3

How this report works

Included are assistants whose catalog entry lists a free plan, a free tier or a monthly price below $100, and that took at least three of Proactive help, Routines, Permissions & privacy and Connected apps. They are ranked by the average of the tests they took, so Muse, Town, Poke, szn, Vellum and Nessi are each missing one. An assistant with no listed price is only included if it lists a free plan or tier.

How to choose

  • Check the missing test. Muse and Town have no Proactive help score, and Poke has no Permissions & privacy score.
  • Check the price. Dots lists $100 a month. Pally lists a free plan; Town lists $15, Poke $19, Ollie $25 and Neo $49 above their free tiers.
  • Look at Permissions & privacy before connecting accounts. Muse and Pally score 9; Town, Neo and Ollie score 8.

What is a cheaper alternative to Dots?

Muse leads at 9.3 over three tests, then Pally at 8.8 and Town at 8.7. All three list a free plan or a free tier.

Do these assistants act on their own?

Most took the Proactive help test, which checks that an assistant speaks up unprompted when it matters, with a fix and without noise. Muse and Town did not take it.

How is this different from the proactive report?

That report ranks only Proactive help. This one adds Routines, Permissions & privacy and Connected apps, and keeps assistants under $100 a month.

Why is Dots not in the ranking?

Dots lists $100 a month in the catalog, which is over this page's price line. Its own scores are on its assistant page.

What users say

Muse · Allison Johnson ·

I'd been using it for all of 40 minutes and already given it my full name, address, credit card number, a photo of my backyard, and the credentials for my home security account login.

Open source
Muse · fnordpiglet ·

First meaningful use of an OpenClaw like system.

Open source
Town · @venturetwins ·

So I asked my @TownAI agent to do it. It collated all the insights + made the deck

Open source
Town · @AlexMontas ·

Regarding @TownAI so much opportunity but it is not proactive enough outside of email.

Open source

Frequently asked questions

Which assistant is best for this?

Muse leads with an average of 9.3, ahead of Pally and Town.

Is there a good free option?

Muse is the highest-ranked assistant with a free plan, averaging 9.3.

How did you test these assistants?

Every assistant got the same published tests, word for word, scored from three checkpoints and the number of corrections it needed. Each test is on the Dimensions page.

Related reports