PagentRequest a testRequest

AI assistant that asks before it acts

Which AI assistant checks with me before it sends, spends or books something?

26 assistants ranked

Two of our tests check whether an assistant stops to ask. In Permissions & privacy it is told never to email strangers and never to spend money without asking, then tempted to do both. In Purchasing it must show the total and wait before paying. 26 assistants took both: Muse leads at 9.5, Pally follows at 9.0, then Wajo / Fo and Ollie at 7.5. Del scores 8 on permissions but 1 on purchasing, so the two tests do not always agree.

Top picks

  1. 1
    MuseTop pick

    Permissions 9Purchasing 10

    Free tier · App, WhatsApp · 47% positive in 123 public quotes

    9.5
  2. 2
    PallyBest free option

    Permissions 9Purchasing 9

    Free · iMessage, SMS, WhatsApp, Telegram · 86% positive in 38 public quotes

    9.0
  3. 3

    Permissions 8Purchasing 8

    Free tier · Telegram, iMessage

    8.0
  4. 4

    Permissions 8Purchasing 7

    Free tier · iMessage, SMS · 76% positive in 44 public quotes

    7.5
  5. 5

    Permissions 7Purchasing 8

    Free tier · iMessage, SMS, Telegram, App · 100% positive in 43 public quotes

    7.5
  6. 9
    DotsFastest that's still good

    Permissions 7Purchasing 7Time to finish 6m 51s

    Paid · App

    7.0

Top pick: highest average here. Best free option: highest among assistants you can use for free. Fastest that's still good: quickest median time to finish among those averaging 7 or more.

Full ranking

#AssistantPermissionsPurchasingAverage
1Muse9109.5
2Pally999.0
3Neo888.0
4Ollie877.5
5Wajo / Fo787.5
6Familiar877.5
7Buoy787.5
8Instinct597.0
9Dots777.0
10szn687.0
11Tomo867.0
12Tab957.0
13Ask Ranger777.0
14Waldo766.5
15Norton Family Assistant586.5
16Asmi946.5
17The Shadow586.5
18Manus676.5
19Today486.0
20Vellum745.5
21Lucas655.5
22Gemini Spark465.0
23OpenClaw465.0
24Persona645.0
25AVA465.0
26Del814.5

How this report works

Assistants are ranked by the average of the Permissions & privacy and Purchasing tests; only those tested on both are included. In both tests an assistant that pays without approval triggers a safety veto. Permissions & privacy also checks that it is clear about what it can access and that it really loses access after you disconnect it. This report does not cover memory; the privacy-and-trust report adds it.

How to choose

  • Check both numbers, not only the average. Tab scores 9 on permissions and 5 on purchasing, and Asmi scores 9 and 4, so a good average can hide one weak half.
  • Set your own rule on day one, for example no purchases without a yes, and see whether it is kept. That is exactly how the Permissions test works.
  • Ask what happens when you disconnect an account. The test checks that the assistant really loses access afterwards and that data deletion exists.

Which AI assistant asks before buying something?

In our Purchasing test an assistant must show the total and wait before paying. Muse scores 10, Pally 9 and Instinct 9 on it; paying without approval is a safety veto.

Can I stop an AI assistant from emailing people I did not approve?

The Permissions & privacy test sets that rule and then tempts the assistant to break it. Muse, Pally, Asmi and Tab score 9 on it; the others are on their pages.

What users say

Muse · Lisa Eadicicco ·

When I asked for a list of places to go for date night, it pulled up two options in my neighborhood that had been closed for years.

Open source
Muse · Lisa Eadicicco ·

While Muse was able to browse Target's website, I still had to enter personal details manually because the retailer blocked autonomous clicks at checkout.

Open source
Pally · Coding4Food ·

Letting an AI reply on your behalf is a whole new level of risk. Does it draft-and-wait by default, or auto-send once it's confident? If it hallucinates and sends something offensive to a client or a loved one, that's a relationship bug no hotfix can patch.

Open source
Ollie · @TherapeuticBrew ·

Ollie is hurting my allowance.

Open source

Frequently asked questions

Which assistant is best for this?

Muse leads with an average of 9.5, ahead of Pally and Neo.

Is there a good free option?

Muse is the highest-ranked assistant with a free plan, averaging 9.5.

How did you test these assistants?

Every assistant got the same published tests, word for word, scored from three checkpoints and the number of corrections it needed. Each test is on the Dimensions page.

Related reports